Saturday 1 August 2015

Failure to Pay Statutory Severance ‘Okay’ because Employer Offered to Do So

Does an employer’s offer of legally required severance pay, provided that the employee signs a full and final release, mitigate against an award of punitive damages if the employer later refuses to pay that legally required severance pay? Surprising as it may seem, in the case of Wyllie v Larche, 2015 ONSC 4747, the Honourable Justice David Price of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice said “yes, it does.”

Saturday 18 July 2015

Advertisement for “Caucasian” Nurse likely Discriminatory

While the CBC was running a feature segment as to whether racism remains an element of Canadian society, a Burlington, Ontario seniors home care company was posting an online advertisement for a “Caucasian RN or RPN.” In an online advertisement posted to Craigslist, shown below, Retire at Home services advertised that a client was "looking for a Caucasian RN or RPN to work shifts that are between eight and 12 hours in length."

The advertisement and subsequent stories touch off a debate as to whether the company had done anything legally wrong and if so what consequences it may face as a result.

Sunday 5 July 2015

"Cynical, Patronizing, Unfair, Impractical, and Expensive" - How Justice Perell described the Partial Summary Judgment Approach to Wrongful Dismissal Cases

Summary judgment, a method of resolving lawsuits without the need for a trial, has long been considered an appropriate means by which to resolve wrongful dismissal cases. The changes made in 2010 to the Rules of Civil Procedure, the rules governing lawsuits in Ontario, served only to increase the popularity of such a process.

But, as this blog has considered on more than one occasion, the speed and efficiency of summary judgment bring with them their own challenges in wrongful dismissal cases; most acutely what to do about the dismissed employee’s duty to mitigate?

In April of 2015, in the case of Markoulakis v SNC-Lavalin Inc., 2015 ONSC 1081 (CanLII) the Honourable Justice Andra Pollak held that the use of the “Trust Approach” previously approved by the Court of Appeal for Ontario in Cronk v. Canadian General Insurance Co. (1995), 25 OR (3d) 505 (CA) was no longer appropriate given the decision of the Supreme Court of Canada in Hryniak v. Mauldin, 2014 SCC 7. That case was summarized by this blog in the post Rushing to Judgment: How to Reconcile the Duty to Mitigate with Summary Judgment in Wrongful Dismissal Cases.

More recently however, on June 29, 2015, the Honourable Justice Paul Perell, also of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, in the case of Paquette v TeraGo Networks Inc., 2015 ONSC 4189 (CanLII) described the "Partial Summary Judgment Approach", where the employee is granted a partial summary judgment and the parties return to court during and or at the end of the notice period for further payments subject to the duty to mitigate, employed by Justice Pollak as “cynical, patronizing, unfair, impractical, and expensive.” Justice Perell specifically mentioned the Markoulakis case in making such comments.

Ouch.

Wednesday 1 July 2015

Is it Discrimination to Pay Bilingual Employees More?

Is it a prohibited form of discrimination to pay a higher salary to employees who can speak both English and French than to those who can speak only English?

In Arnold v. Stream Global Services, 2010 HRTO 424 (CanLII), the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario said “non”, deciding that paying bilingual workers significantly more than those who spoke exclusively English was not a prohibited form of discrimination.

Saturday 27 June 2015

Employee Owed More Severance Because He was Fired in June

Does it matter in which month an employee is fired? According to decision from the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, Fraser v Canerector Inc., 2015 ONSC 2138 (CanLII), the answer is “yes.”

In his reasons for decision granting the plaintiff 50% more reasonable notice than he otherwise would have awarded, the Honourable Justice Sean F. Dunphy wrote:

I must also account for the time of year when his employment was terminated in assessing reasonable notice. Mr. Fraser’s employment was terminated in June and it was quite foreseeable that hiring decisions at his level might have needed to be delayed somewhat due to the summer months in order to account for vacation schedules of key decision-makers.

Wednesday 24 June 2015

Termination from Employment While on Disability Leave

There is never a good time to be fired from one’s job. However, some times are worse than others. A particularly bad time to be fired is while absent from work on disability leave.

While there are few definitive answers when it comes to the law, this post will take a look at some of the most common questions concerning termination from employment during disability leave.

Saturday 20 June 2015

HRTO Awards $150,000 to Temporary Foreign Worker following Sexual Assault by Employer

The Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario ordered an employer to pay $150,000.00 to a former temporary foreign worker after finding that the owner and principal of the company had engaged in a series of prolonged unwanted sexual solicitations and advances against her, including sexual assaults.

O.P.T. v. Presteve Foods Ltd., 2015 HRTO 675 (CanLII), now stands as the present ‘high-water mark’ for damages as compensation for injury to dignity, feelings and self-respect.