Showing posts with label Justice Cary Boswell. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Justice Cary Boswell. Show all posts

Monday 4 October 2021

"Close Only Counts in Horseshoes." ONSC finds Reasonableness of Plaintiff’s Position a Relevant Factor in Awarding Costs

Litigation is an expensive business. It is not for the risk-averse or the faint of heart. There are winners and there are losers. And it is a well-established convention in our civil justice system that losers pay the winners a significant portion of their costs.

Wrongful dismissal cases are especially perilous; especially where the defendant employer alleges cause for dismissal.

So what happens when the employee loses? Is the reasonableness of the plaintiff’s position a relevant factor in awarding costs of the case?

In Goruk v. Greater Barrie Chamber of Commerce,2021 ONSC 6290 (CanLII) Justice Cary Boswell held that it is.